The Effect of Client Characteristics on the Negotiation Tactics of Auditors

Richard C. Hatfield
University of Alabama

Christopher P. Agoglia
University of Massachusetts at Amherst

Maria H. Sanchez
Rider University – Department of Accounting

Journal of Accounting Research, December 2008

Abstract:

Although the financial statements of an organization are considered a product of management, prior research suggests that a company’s financial statements may be affected by the negotiation strategy employed by the auditor when resolving audit differences with management. However, little subsequent research has discussed the potential strategies that auditors may employ during the negotiation process. Our study extends the literature by investigating, in a post-Sarbanes-Oxley environment, whether auditors will employ a reciprocity-based strategy for the resolution of audit differences and what client characteristics (client management’s negotiating style and client retention risk) will increase the extent to which it is utilized. Such a strategy involves bringing inconsequential items to management and subsequently waiving these items in an effort to encourage management to be more cooperative in the posting of significant income-decreasing adjustments. The results of our study indicate that client management’s negotiating style and retention risk have an interactive effect on auditors’ use of a reciprocity-based strategy. Specifically, auditors are more likely to utilize a reciprocity-based strategy when management’s negotiating style is competitive and client retention risk is high. Interestingly, the end result of the negotiation process is essentially identical (i.e., similar items are posted), regardless of client characteristics or the auditor’s utilization of a reciprocity-based strategy. Thus, it appears that use of a reciprocity-based strategy does not affect the quality of the financial statements, but simply facilitates the process of posting significant items.

The Effect of Client Characteristics on the Negotiation Tactics of Auditors

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Tu dirección de correo no será publicada.


*


Google Analytics